Question: I recently took out a loan to expand my farm, but with interest rates fluctuating, I’m unsure if I should fix my loan or keep it at a variable rate.

The loan is for €200,000, and while I can manage the repayments right now, I’m concerned about potential rate increases in the future. I could be in trouble if they start to rise. I want to know more about the pros and cons of fixed rates. What should I consider when deciding whether to fix my loan or not?

Answer: This is a common concern for many in the agri sector, especially when financial stability is key to managing unpredictable elements like weather or market prices. It’s tempting to make your loan repayments predictable when so many other things are not.

That said, whether to fix your loan or stick with a variable rate depends on several factors. Let’s look at the bigger picture by diving into the pros and cons of fixing a loan, along with what else you should consider.

Pros of fixing a loan

  • Predictability in repayments: Fixing your loan provides certainty – this is by far the biggest benefit. Your monthly repayments will remain the same for the fixed period, regardless of what happens to interest rates. This predictability can help with budgeting, especially in an industry where income can be irregular. It’s one less thing to worry about.
  • Protection against rising interest rates: If you believe interest rates are likely to rise in the near future, fixing your loan could save you money. You’ll be insulated from any increases, which means your repayment amount won’t go up, even if market rates do.
  • Financial security: Knowing exactly what your repayments will be allows you to plan better, reducing financial stress. This can be particularly valuable during tough farming seasons, when cashflow may be tight and you want to limit spending.

    • Cons of fixing a loan

  • Limited flexibility: Fixed loans are less flexible compared to variable loans. If rates fall, you won’t benefit from the reduction, and if you need to refinance or want to pay off the loan early, you may face hefty penalties.
  • Potentially higher costs: Fixed-rate loans generally start with a higher interest rate than variable loans. Over time, if interest rates don’t rise, or if they fall, you could end up paying more than you would with a variable loan. The downside of month-to-month steadiness may be a higher overall repayment.
  • Exit fees and penalties: Most fixed loans come with exit fees if you decide to pay off the loan early or refinance. These fees can be substantial, so it’s important to factor them into your decision.

    • Key considerations

    How do you decide if fixing is actually best for you? Here are our five important considerations:

    1. Current market conditions:

    Analyse the current and projected interest rate trends. If rates are expected to rise, fixing might be wise. However, if they are expected to stay stable or decrease, a variable rate might save you money in the long run.

    2. Length of the fixed period:

    Consider how long you want to fix the loan for. Typical fixed terms range from one to five years. Longer terms provide more security but also come with higher interest rates and potential exit fees. The duration of the loan could be a deciding factor.

    3. Your financial situation:

    It’s important to assess your farm’s cash flow and financial stability. If your farm’s income is stable, you might be able to handle the risk of variable rates. But if your income fluctuates or you anticipate tight cash flow, the stability of a fixed rate could be beneficial and could save you some worry.

    4. Potential for early repayment:

    Consider your plans for the future. If you anticipate paying off the loan early or even refinancing, a fixed loan might not be the best option due to the possibility of hefty exit fees.

    5. Professional advice:

    If in doubt, talk it out. A financial adviser can help you weigh up the pros and cons based on your specific situation and the current economic environment.

    Should you fix your loan?

  • Predictability: Fixed loans offer stable repayments, ideal for tight budgets.
  • Rate protection: Fixed loans can shield you from rising interest rates.
  • Flexibility: Variable loans offer more freedom if rates drop, but they come with less security.
  • Costs: Fixed loans may start with higher rates and include exit penalties.

    • Read more

    Money Mentor: joining a herd number – what you need to know